Ask the Thoughtful Pastor: Idolatry and Contrasting Points of View

(c) Samantha Sophia, Unsplash Images
(c) Samantha Sophia, Unsplash Images

In Exodus, God hands down the Ten Commandments. The second commandment forbids any graven images. Later in the same book, God tells Moses how the tabernacle is to be built and decorated — and all those chapters seem to instruct Moses to have craftsmen and women to build, overlay, sculpt, weave and make jewelry for holy rites. Isn’t this a violation of the second commandment?

A little background first: Exodus 20 and Deuteronomy 5 list the first ten commandments but there are actually 613 different commandments. The include 365 “Don’ts” and 248 “Do’s.”

The familiar first ten, however, give the overview of “love God and love neighbor.”

One through four tell us how to love God. Summary: Don’t exchange the worship of the Creator for the idolatry of the created.

Five to ten tell us how to love our neighbors. Summary: be good to your parents, don’t cheat on your spouse and don’t do things to others that you don’t want them to do to you–like lying and stealing and being so consumed by envy that you can’t be genuinely decent to them.

The “graven images” thing comes out of the early Israel religious context. People have always created forms that are likenesses of important things, particularly assured fertility and political and military power. Ultimately, those created forms then became themselves objects of worship.

These 613 laws set aside Israel as religiously unique from the surrounding cultures. Using the artistic abilities and things of beauty at their disposal, the Israelites created an exquisite place to meet God. Here they entered into that mysterious Presence, symbolized by a cloud during the day and a pillar of fire by night.

That place, the Tabernacle, was never to be worshipped itself. It was, however, to display the best and the brightest of human creativity.

When humans imagine and create things of beauty, we become most like God–those created in the image of God, the imaginative Creator of the cosmos. We are to use our creations as a means of worshiping God with heart, mind, soul and strength.

This in no way violates the commandments against making idols. However, when those objects of creation become the core of our lives, when the preservation or adoration or manipulation of the objects takes center stage and leaves us unwilling or unable to offer to God unfettered worship, then we have indeed crossed the line.


Royalty Free Stock Photo: 3d man sitting with red question mark over white ID 35343815 © Dreammasterphotographer |
Royalty Free Stock Photo: 
ID 35343815 © Dreammasterphotographer |

How does one, who recognizes they have already made up their mind about something, pick out the contradictory arguments?  And, once picked out, analyze them for what they are worth?  

Periodically I meditate on how little I know. I ponder the size of the universe, the miracle of life, the power of subatomic particles. the mystery of love.

Or as the wisdom writer who is quoted in the Biblical book of Proverbs states it, “Three things are too wonderful for me, four that I can’t figure out: the way of an eagle in the sky, the way of a snake on the rock, the way of a ship out on the open sea, and the way of a man with a young woman.” (Prov. 30:18-19, CEB).

I also make myself read and study opposing points of view from my own. I work to understand why they might be true to someone else when they seem so patently false to me. When really on a roll, I become aware that my own reality may be significantly different from someone else’s

I’m a short, poorly coordinated, depth-perception challenged, profoundly left-handed woman. One day I was speaking with a tall, accomplished athletic male with excellent eyesight and depth perception.

In conversation, I realized how differently we perceived the physical world. To him, it was friendly, easy to navigate, full of useful tools and unquestioned comfort. For me, obstacles lurk in every sidewalk crack and piece of equipment engineered for the dominant right-handed world.

Something he might describe as “a piece of cake” looked like a near impossibility for me.

So I repeat this mantra, “I may be wrong.” Let’s face it: none of us has a handle on “objective” truth. We deceive ourselves most when we insist that “I’ve got all the facts and I’ve made the only right decision.” There is no such thing with our limited and filtered brains.

To suggest we can analyze the arguments of others with something like an unbiased logic, then, becomes highly problematic. A possibility: try generously arguing the points of those who stand in direct opposition to your own decisions and see how well they stand up. Do so without attacking character or personality, but with acknowledging the possibility of a world considerably different from the one you know.

You will see greater possibilities and reasonable claims for multiple truths which may help inform your own.


All questions are welcome. You can email your questions to, “like” her Facebook Page, use this form to send them or message her on Twitter. You can also send a question through conventional mail to the following address: Thoughtful Pastor, 314 E. Hickory St., Denton, TX, 76202.

[Note: a version of this column will appear in the Friday, February 12, 2016  print and online editions of The Denton Record Chronicle.]

4 thoughts on “Ask the Thoughtful Pastor: Idolatry and Contrasting Points of View

  1. A good example would be the bronze serpent that Moses ordered to be made as a cure for the Israelites who were suffering. It was made according to God’s specifications, however, after several generations, it became a god-image and it had to be destroyed because people were worshipping it more than they were worshipping the God who cured people through it.

    I’m something of a Devil’s Advocate – I inherited the tendency from my grandfather. When I see nine people agreeing on a thought, it’s my nature to look for holes, bad reasoning, logical fallicies even if I agree with their position to some extent, it doesn’t keep me from questioning them. Sadly, when I do leave a comment, all too often people just want others to agree with them and I’m labelled a troll. You don’t really have to have an opinion either way, just be well-informed and know what you’re talking about and you’ll find it easier to see the difference between bad logic and profound insight.


      1. I appreciate that. I enjoy having a diverse set of perspectives because I happen to know that nobody knows everything. I have blind-spots in my theology that are the same ones that Baptists have, but a Methodist might be able to show me something Baptists can’t see. I’ve been learning a lot in the year since I switched denominations and even more from the internet as I try to understand what makes us all different and what we’re all on the same page about.


        1. I think the day I quit learning from others is the day I need to die. But I have met an incredible number of closed-minded persons–no new facts or ideas permitted. I suppose it is safer to live that way, but also far less interesting.

          Liked by 1 person

What do you think? I'd love to hear from you! Abusive comments may be removed at the discretion of the blog moderator.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s